2021
Madeline Gohn | Messiah College 
Jordyn Resetar | Southern New Hampshire 
Olivia Lillich | Mary Baldwin University
Shauna Stotler | Cabrini University
Dorian Ilyes | Cabrini University
Kelleigh Pollock | Seton Hill University
Bailey Smith | Delaware Valley University
Taylor Portzline | Neumann University

2020
Amaya Bowman | Mount St. Mary's
Sydni Carroll | Sacred Heart University
Hannah Gartrell | University of Akron
Brianna Kessler | Muhlenberg College
Lauren Little | Army West Point
Emily Sicinski | Penn State - Mont Alto
Amanda Smith | Carnegie Mellon
Austin Swallow | Frostburg State University

2019
Barbara Black | Washington Adventist
Marguerite DeFranco | University of Pitt - Bradford
Breanna Harvey | Bowie State University
Madison Jones | Marietta College
Hailey Kessinger | University of Mount Olive
Kelsie Merriman | Keiser University

2018
Rachel Colbus | New York University
Courtney Coppersmith | University of Maryland - BC
Briana DiCandeloro | Moravian College
Taylor Glover | Shenandoah University
Jordyn Goodman | Coker College
Elena Rosas | Messiah College
Camryn Rothrock | Lock Haven University
Karlee Stocksdale | Messiah College
Nikki Stone | Shenandoah University
Paige Weekly | York College of PA

2017
Samantha Amateau | Shenandoah University
Marlee Carroll | Bridgewater University
Briannah Dobson | Bloomsburg University
Gabriel Ilyes | Ursinus College
Julia Wivell | Indiana University of PA

2016
Haylee Anders | Messiah College
Jaelyn Harbold | Messiah College
Madisyn Johnson | McDaniel College
Cassie Rickrode | McDaniel College
Kylie Shreiner | Pensylvania College of Technology
McKenzie Somers | Gettysburg College
Kaitlin Yealy | McDaniel College

2015
Brooke Day | Kutztown University
Kyla Caruso | Messiah College
Carrie Fix | Messiah College
Kirsten Hertzog | Millersville University
Deanna Laughman | Eastern University
Kayla Merriman | Texas A&M International
Hayley Norton | Saint Francis of PA
Ashley Werner | York College of Pennsylvania

2014
Kelsey Clever | Eastern University

2013
Lexus Allen | University of Maryland - Eastern Shore
Nicole Ayers | University of Sciences